Kindle or the Ipad?

A  couple of weeks ago, Steve Jobs of Apple Corporation introduced his audience and other techies to the the new gadget called the iPad. As a prelude to that fantastic presentation, he confirmed that Apple has evolved into a mobile devices corporations since it ships MacBooks, iPods, iPhones and the rest. Among the many amazing things that the iPad can do is to act as a mini computer that can handle the word processing and other applications that would include games, email access, photo storage and retrieval, music and an electronic reader. Because this blogger comes late to this issue, I will not try to sum up the many wondrous other things that the gadget is capable of.

However, the conventional wisdom of the Apple enthusiasts is that the Kindle is nearly dead because the iPad is certainly bound to replace it as the e-book reader of choice. As someone who has just recently acquired the Kindle 2 and is just reading the first book on it, I am inclined to disagree with these flowery assessments of the iPad's inevitable conquest of the market for electronic gadgets for readers. 

Judging from my considerable research and limited use of the Kindle 2, I am wont to disagree with the idea that this will completely bring Amazon's Kindle to an abrupt stop. First, I agree fully that the iPad as demonstrated by Steve jobs here is impressive because it can do a lot of things and is therefore not a dedicated instrument for readers. Instead, it does many things out of which reading e-books is merely one of them. To my mind, dedicated readers who are attracted to the Kindle for the reason that it makes reading easy and convenient will not all be impressed with the bell and whistles on the iPad. 

Additionally, my comparison of the prices for the Kindle 2 and the iPad leads me to the thought that the added features of the iPad  places it at a disadvantage in respect of the e entry-level Kindle 2. I must add that apple rarely gets its pricing wrong and that this price will predictably fall when the gadget reaches some critical mass within a couple of years. Still, at US$ 499, the price signal is that this is an Apple product that has wonderful graphics and aesthetic appeal but serious readers are used to the white page. 

In essence, I wager that the iPad will not wipe out the Kindle and that the effect that the former will have may be overstated because of the aesthetic appeal of the gadget and the surefooted legacy of the Apple corporation. As the gadget for a serious book reader, the Kindle is still the standard. I think that what this competition is a mere trumpet call to the publishers to take the industry seriously enough. I am certain that publishing will not be the same again.