Monday, June 25, 2012

A Survey of Rio+20

The Rio+20 Conference ended over the last weekend and many reports suggest that this meeting achieved nothing partly because the expectations were too high, views so far apart and the real expectations not clearly spelt out. In this piece, Jagdish Bhagwati states that he is unsurprised because of many reasons starting with the emptiness of the phrase "sustainable development". Not only has this term of reference become cliche' but it also illustrates why those who insist on it as a precondition for development are oblivious of the real tradeoffs that poor people need. In the short essay, he also states how matters unconnected to the environment are allowed onto the agenda and become part of the declarations in a way that shows the inability to focus on small and smart solutions.

Unlike Jagdish, I have no problem with any self-appointed group of activists trying to hoist their pet policy solutions on the rest of us. I would rather that they understood much better that multilateral institutions that take on every agenda are the best candidates for failure on all of them. And as a person who attends smaller conferences on select trade and regulatory matters, I think that a conference dedicated to global growth would be far more useful than Rio+40. The environment is certainly important but all who come for the conference must recall that this was about the environment and that the train can only pull in so much. The framing of global problems is one of the skills that today's society lacks.  

Thursday, June 14, 2012

Younger Workers and Property Ownership

Every person with even a little knowledge about economics would have been cautious about the resumption of growth after the financial crisis and subsequent recession. Among the lessons of the crisis and its effects is that there is no such thing as an asset that cannot lose value. Home ownership may be desirable but this crisis emphatically revealed that homes are not necessarily assets of a different category and when the prices rise beyond reason, then they will come down and leave many owners with huge and unserviceable mortgages. 

With that view in mind, I get a little surprised that articles that fail to caution against the impression that ownership of homes is imperative for all and that rental is an inferior form of consumption of housing services. This piece in the Telegraph is one of many in the British press that has provided summaries of a study undertaken by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation in which it found that the effects of slow growth and lower wages for younger workers will be seen in their inability to acquire homes and may have to resort to renting houses. To be fair, the study brings up the sound economic argument that it is useful to try and improve the efficiency in the house rental markets to ensure that it works better. 

Having just read through the publication by the Institute of Economic Affairs on housing in the United Kingdom, it is clear to me that there should be an broad understanding that rental of residential property is not necessarily inferior to outright ownership especially where individual incomes cannot match prevailing prices. That report goes into comparisons of basic benchmarks for assessing property markets and isolates regulatory gaps and missteps that frames the housing policy in UK in far better light. Its not a bad thing at all that younger people will not own homes because the gap between their incomes and the houses shows that houses are far too expensive to own and even for those with that income, it may be useful to carefully gauge whether renting is better.     

Saturday, June 09, 2012

From Absurd Belief to Atrocities

"Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities." Voltaire 

Tuesday, June 05, 2012

Speed Reading Test

I encountered this page on an application that allows one to test the ability to read quickly and provides a benchmark in a spectrum from high school students to college professors. My score was much slower than I am sure that I am but still impressed me. I embed it for blog readers to try.


Thursday, May 31, 2012

India: The Bungling Democracy

I have argued on this blog here and other posts that India and China represent a natural experiment that will help to answer the question about the place of democracy and authoritarianism in longer term development. In short, my claim has been that in spite of a slower rate of growth and a smaller economy, India is bound to catch up soon and will over time become a large economy owing to its more open political system. In sum, the argument is that democracy is not necessarily a hindrance to India's long term growth and that China will of necessity have to go through bumps that may derail it substantially.

In spite of my being bullish about India, reading stories such as this in the NYT makes me really frustrated at India's political leadership. Granted that the Congress party has to navigate in order to keep its coalition in place, I cannot avoid the argument that India's growth is slowing and that it does not show any signs of catching up with China at all. Indeed, in spite of China's own domestic political and economic difficulties, India's leaders still have an inferior record of economic management. In many respects, the benefits that India gained from the bold economic reforms initiated under Manmohan Singh two decades ago are exhausted now and he lacks either the courage or the ability to make another long-overdue round of reforms to open up the economy. 

Given the state of affairs, it is just possible that India's catch up period will be unduly extended because of the delays in cutting back red tape and substantial regulatory and tax reforms. On the political side, India's bungling, in spite of the fact that it has an indubitably bright man as prime minister will embolden those who consider democracy as a liability for fast growth. Please get up and sprint!

 

Wednesday, May 30, 2012

Should Zoos Be Conservation Parks?

If asked, I would answer that the primary purpose for the existence of a zoo is to assemble a number of animals that would meet the curiosity of people who would visit and pay some money to cover costs. By this definition, the functions of a zoo are largely for the entertainment of visitors. Reading Leslie Kaufmann's article in the NYT tells me that there is substantial pressure on successful zoos to incorporate the conservation of threatened species into their business model. It is immediately clear that an accreditation body is trying to use the conservation of species as a new criteria for certifying zoos in the United States.

It is altogether understandable that it would be a big advantage to be able to display a wide range of animals as part of building the experience for visitors. However, I think that the management of zoos should not be compelled to change the business model to incorporate conservation because that change will imply different costs and requirements in terms of staff and operations. To start with, some of the fauna that are arguably in danger of extinction may be unknown to the visitors to zoos and therefore the diversion of resources towards saving them may not be a cost effective policy. As stated, tensions will inevitably arise because of the required trade offs where the more popular species as elephants may not be in as much danger. In the eyes of many school children, to visit a zoo to see a toad or unique species of frog in place of the elephant and the Zebra may not be acceptable.

Clearly therefore, the approach should be to allow individual zoos to choose the species in which they would specialize and let the conservation efforts be handled by others that are resourced for it. It will become clear in good time whether these models could co-exist or be run separately. Ensuring the restoration of numbers of some of the species with low numbers may in the end be even beyond some zoos. they should therefore be allowed to provide entertainment only.  Conservation requires concentrating resources on a few species and this limits the variety within zoos.    

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Promise of National ID Sytems

Soon after reading the book Imagining India by Nandan Nilekani, one of the founders of Infosys, I learned that the author's proposal for a form of identification mechanism for individual citizens had been accepted by the government. In the book, he mentions that the absence of an identification document for most Indian citizens leads to a lot of fraud in government assistance for social programmes. It is understandable that a technology solution to this would reduce cost and ensure cost effective delivery of the services to deserving people. While reading that book, it immediately came to my mind that the retention of all sets of data on individuals has implications for their rights and their relationship to governments.

The Republic of South Africa has also commenced a citizen registration system mentioned here by its Minister for Home Affairs. In that piece, it is argued that there is the need to consolidate all registration and identification documents in the form of a smart card that would enable citizens to be registered for voting, driving and other interactions with the state. Needless to mention, my libertarian instincts tell me that this endeavor is not only bad for liberty but also technically unsound. To start with, the consolidation of all forms of identification under a single smart card may seem smart but simply shows that an individual is more vulnerable because a large amount of data is available in one place. Secondly, I see the tendency for well-meaning state officials to overstate the power of technology in the statement that this card is absolutely secure and cannot be breached. To my mind, that is such a preposterous statement that can only have been made up or used by the firm that is marketing this system to governments that would not care to audit that system.  

So to add my conclusion, I am certain that the quest to make identification of individuals may have some social value. What I am less certain of is whether it needs to be in form of governments collecting and maintaining a lot of data for individuals in one place. Now, the technology savvy thief knows which database to breach and find out more than they should about some citizens.    

Monday, May 28, 2012

Changing The Penalty Shootout Rule

Several days ago, Chelsea Football Club won the UEFA championship in a penalty shootout against the FC Bayern Munich. In the eyes of many purists and soccer pundits, the winning team was less deserving based on an assessment of the tactics adopted and the distribution of skills displayed on that day.  Simply put, the Chelsea FC are an inferior footballing side to the Bayern Munich team irrespective of the outcome. Most of the pundits were concerned that the triumph of an inferior side could spark a widespread imitation that could reduce the entertainment value of this high profile tournament. As if the condemnation was not enough, the president of FIFA spoke about the manner of that triumph and suggested that the sports discipline of soccer should consider the development of an alternative to penalty shootouts.  

In my view, that response is too drastic and perhaps denigrates the hard work that one team put in to ensure that it won. My view, is that notwithstanding the justifiable disappointment that many purists and fans of the game may feel, this reaction is too drastic and altogether unjustified. For a start, it assumes that winning a penalty shootout is manifestation of no preparation when that portion of the game is itself very technical and skill-driven. Secondly, it feels as if the revision of laws is driven by animus towards one team's tactics in spite of the fact that they represent a legitimate approach to the game. It may be ugly soccer but is within the rules. Finally, I think that the officials of FIFA and administrators of the game must be careful because there may be unintended consequences of the anticipated changes too. 

It is worthy to recall that Formula 1 has had so many technical changes to the sport with the ostensible reason of making it more interesting and simply changed the dominant sides from one team to another. My advise would be to let teams learn to cope by creating new approaches to ensure that they triumph against the more defensive minded sides. It is my understanding that fans tend to reward the teams that play more entertaining soccer. If some clubs make the trade off in order to win tournaments, then that should be acceptable to all.     

Friday, May 25, 2012

A Review of Ruchir Sharma's Breakout Nations


Breakout Nations: In Pursuit of the Next Economic MiraclesBreakout Nations: In Pursuit of the Next Economic Miracles by Ruchir Sharma
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

What is much better than a book that sensibly cautions against taking the conventional wisdom without regular review?. Ruchir Sharma has taken on the assumption that the BRICs are guaranteed to dominate world affairs (economic and political) for the medium term. That the BRICs have grown at an unprecedented scale is not in dispute but perhaps some caution should be taken in the assumption that the four have an easy and guaranteed path to the attainment of high income levels that would eventually dwarf the US and European economies.

History alone suggests that high growth as maintained by these countries tends to be episodic and is often difficult to maintain. Forecasts and claims that the BRICs story growth story of the early years of the millennium is bound to continue should be carried with more caution than analysts acknowledge. The primary claim is that all the BRICs benefited from a surfeit of cheap money from the more developed economies and may be unable to repeat their performance in the future.

More interesting is the author's finding that there are other countries whose prospects are far better than individual members of the BRICs group. Granted, not all of these Breakout Nations have large populations or huge internal markets but they have the basics right. In this group are Turkey, South Korea, Taiwan and Indonesia.

Among other profound conclusions, the author sensibly advises that it is more prudent to analyze the prospects of individual countries without relational on bogus quantification and indices that aggregate different countries.    


Wednesday, May 23, 2012

E-Books March On

I have eschewed any arguments about the superiority of one format of books over the other. My main reason being that it has been well-established that people who read intensely often acquire both digital and  physical books. To a student of economics, it is not accurate to view one as the perfect substitute for the other. Indeed, it has been demonstrated that upon acquiring the Kindle, readers go ahead to purchase more books in either format.

An article by Tom Chivers of the Daily Telegraph makes that point in a subtle way though he appears to be partial to the physical book. That notwithstanding, he shows that a large proportion of books read today are still in the paper format and it will be quite a while before the e-books take over completely. He is sympathetic to the fact that large bookstores will be adversely affected and will probably be rendered extinct. My view is that the large bookstores will not necessarily become extinct but will shrink considerably and the economics of the bookstore will have to adapt to the ease of acquisition of books in competing formats.

Since the adoption of e-books is growing faster while books literature in paper form is stagnant at best, it cannot be too far away before publishers have to reckon with this change. Stores will be smaller and books may be delivered based on real-time demand. That cannot be a bad thing for all readers.  

Monday, May 21, 2012

Big City Team Wins With Bad Soccer

Over the last weekend, a record for soccer was established in Europe where Chelsea FC won the European Club Champions Cup (UEFA) cup after beating Bayern Munich of Germany. In that win, Chelsea FC established its own record because this was the first time that Chelsea are the soccer champions of Europe. Many journalists also noted that it marked the end of a jinx where the English team and teams based in England have consistently lost to German opposition in penalties.  

Typical of events such as these is that the analysis captures trite issues with every pundit attempting to explain why the victory and loss were altogether inevitable. To my mind, the one factor that only very keen analysts would have noted and even explored is the fact that this event marked the break with big cities winning this championship. This obscure fact is one that I realized while reading this book by Simon Kuper and Stefan Szymanski. In one of the chapters, they state the curious fact that none of the soccer clubs based in Europe's largest cities such as London, Paris or Istanbul have had a team win that trophy while teams domiciled in smaller cities such as Marseilles, Manchester  and Milan have achieved that feat. 

With Chelsea's improbable win, it is clear that some change has taken place and big-city clubs outside Madrid may have found a way to crack this problem. The event is also an achievement in the sense that it proves that a team that consistently pumps a single-investor's money into soccer in Europe could ultimately win that prize even if it makes no profit while doing that. Without data and more incisive analysis, it is possible that pundits are making too much of a single event but one sees that many teams will probably be encouraged to be pragmatic in terms of game strategy and win regardless of the aesthetics. Maybe south American soccer will be what helps the game retain the claim to being the beautiful game. Chelsea are winners but won with no style or respect for entertainment value. Since the club is making no money while at it, I am not thrilled that the better team, Bayern Munich, lost. 

Friday, May 18, 2012

AA's Too Frequent Flyer Plan

source: www.aa.com
Many corporations are interested in creating a long-term commitment with their highest margin clients. In the quest to do that, the marketing professionals within firms sometimes generate ideas intended to ensure that business relationship with selected clients are maintained. One real example of that is the American Airlines' AAirpass which was intended to be a one-time upfront payment for selected customers in exchange for unlimited travel in the future. It is understandable that in the thinking of the corporation, this was meant to ensure upfront payment for a service that would be consumed in the future.

Washington Post reports here that the lifetime travel pass was initially sold for US$ 250, 000 and was adjusted a number of times thereafter. For a student of applied economics, it is clear that here is an instance in which the designers of the AAirpass failed t properly reckon with the fact that ownership of the pass would change travel behaviour for some customers. With the benefit of hindsight, it is clear that the AAirpass was purchased by individuals who would in turn trade on it and travelled far more frequently and longer distances. That the corporation resorted to use of detectives to detect the alleged abuses and ended up suing some customers is less a demonstration of deviousness of the customers than the fact that the marketing team that came up with this idea understood very little and crated a poorly designed product.  

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

Poverty and Entrepreneurship

"The enterprises of the poor often seem more a way to buy a job when a more conventional employment opportunity is not available than a reflection of a particular entrepreneurial urge." Abhijit V. Banerjee and Esther Duflo in, Poor Economics. Page 226

Monday, May 14, 2012

Defining Yahoo!

Many people underestimate what t takes to run a large corporation such as Yahoo and to make it a success while even many more mistakenly believe that CEO's determine all the outcomes of such firms. It is rather unfortunate that Yahoo! has had to lose its CEO because of a misstatement in his resume just at the same time that it has been struggling greatly to revive its businesses. I hate to kick a person who is on the floor and therefore will not overly condemn Scott Thompson for the error on his resume. However, I am unsure that having a computer science degree on its own would mean that he was more capable than not. In my view, his departure is about material misstatements that could have misled the recruiters.

That aside, I think that the most perceptive piece that I have read about this unfortunate incident is by Charles Arthur, the technology editor of the Guardian. He suggests here that the present circumstances show that the successor CEO must answer an important question about what Yahoo! is. To be honest, that question is one that not many people can answer for the firms that they work for or purport to run. Added to the fact that in Yahoo!'s arena are Google, Facebook, Twitter and many more, I would not answer that question in a thousand words or on a postcard. It may even be a question that has no answer. But as Charles suggests, it is possible that the inability to answer that question convincingly shows that there is cluttered thinking in that firm.

I hope that any readers of this blog would venture an answer as I am wondering whether Yahoo!'s trajectory is an illustration of creative destruction at work.

Wednesday, May 09, 2012

Atul Gawande's Prescription for Complex Systems




I have found that Atul Gawande is a rarity among professionals because he not only writes very clearly but is also eloquent. I pasted a quote from him in this blog post after having read his latest book, The Checklist Manifesto. In this TED talk, he goes into a lucid discussion about the complexity that a highly trained surgeon encounters today and how this has almost led to definite limits in their ability to perform many functions. The idea he comes up with is not to apply more technology or other fixes but just to use a checklist. As he says it, this has been tested in real surgery conditions across different nations and has had incredible results than one would have guessed. I cannot help but think that a well-thought checklist leads to benefits that surpass a blockbuster drug.  

Questioning Property Appraisals

It is a good idea to consider the opinions of professionals who have studied and taken some time to understand an industry or portions of it. However, this general advise does not mean that every industry is based on the fact that practitioners will always provide value. Reading this article on the valuation of commercial property has led me to ask whether the industry is based on any objective criteria. As the article states, a study was undertake and discovered that the valuations were error prone one way or the other by up to 40%. Impliedly therefore, many firms that trusted some of the reports presented by commercial property appraisals that were not very useful because of the margins of error. 

This leads me to ask that with such large margins of error, is commercial property valuation really a profession? As the story states, the findings of the study may be taken with caution because the market is depressed and that may have contributed to the differential in the realized and estimated values. Irrespective of that salient fact, I am convinced that appraisals should be conducted differently in order to avoid the impression created by valuers that their valuations and completely solid. I see no perfect solution except that valuations or appraisals should include numbers within a range. This may be difficult because some appraisers may base their fees on the value of the property. 

As expected, the industry practitioners resort to the fact that a number of firms are responsible for improper appraisal because of the competition for fees. In my view, it matters not because there is equal incentive for the better appraisers to achieve better results for the same price. One can only see a change when the demand side of this service gets more serious in asking what the value of an appraisal is.


Monday, April 30, 2012

Harvard Responds to Monopoly Publishers

Reading this article by Ian Sample of the Guardian reminded me of a conversation that I held with a professional economist who studies competition policy. I asked about his most recent research area and he mentioned to me that like many other micro-economists, he was concerned about the cost of academic journals in the discipline. In his view, many of them received the input of working professionals at low cost and then charged well above the marginal price. Going ahead,  he asserted that this state of affairs would only get worse because the main journals in the subject of economics were each a monopoly in its area and therefore had no incentive to charge as close to the margin as possible.  

Coming down several years later, it seems that the market power of major academic journals has persisted and that the academic institutions are reacting to the overall cost in addition to the relentless rise in prices every year. Harvard University's Librarian, has issued a memorandum to its staff suggesting that they ought to reconsider and possibly cut their relationships with leading publishers of academic journals. It takes the power of a a top university with other clout of its own to bring his issue to the fore. 

In my view, the fact that universities and scholars contribute most of the content alone does not mean that the pricing policy by publishers must favor them. The really interesting part for a student of economics is the realization that these institutions are using their understanding of their contribution to journals to try and bargain for lower costs. I also think that it is not enough to merely withhold association with the publishers. It would be a far more interesting point if they brought to fruition the idea of open access to academic knowledge. this would force a tactical response from the publishers and the competition would without lead to a reduction of the price of knowledge towards the margin.    

  

Formula 1 and Freedom Indices

People with more than a casual interest in sports have probably encountered arguments or wondered whether athletes from autocratic governments differ from others in performance across sports disciplines. More recently, I have come to consider whether the Formula 1 franchise has been expanding its races towards in a way that reflects interest in the style of political management or not. In the last decade, Formula 1 has grown in terms of demand for races across the Asian continent and this culminated in bringing in new races in Bahrain, China and India. 

It is noteworthy that the hosting of a Formula 1 race requires investments in top level infrastructure in addition to being able to attract substantial corporate sponsorship. The three new entrants into the Formula 1 races have different political economy indicators even if they share attributes that make then attractive places. To start with, India is a large and growing economy and an unqualified democracy.  China is at this moment in time, the most sought after investment destination and one that would be attractive to the owners of the Formula 1 franchise because of this fact that global corporations are chasing its large market. Bahrain, is a smaller country whose citizens are not politically free at all but is a nation whose rulers have a lot of public money to pour into the construction of a state of the art race track. 

A couple of weeks back, the Grand prix race in Bahrain was held with visible agitation from its population. Whereas all the technical requirements were in place, the demonstrations that occurred during the weekend of the race led to the loss of a life in addition to disturbances that did concern some teams. To my mind, the Formula 1 is a private business and its owner(s) are perfectly entitled to seek partnerships for hosting races wherever they can. That notwithstanding, I think that Formula 1 should begin to carefully survey indices that measure the degree of political and economic freedom as it chases the next set of partners for hosting races. When a business of this stature begins to expand aggressively towards the most repressive regimes in the world, it is time for its owners to take some time and think clearly and ensure that they are sure that this expansion model will remain valid. 

Wednesday, April 25, 2012

US Dollar Replaces Zimbabwean Dollar

In my reckoning, few countries have a more opinionated, if wrongheaded leader that the African nation of Zimbabwe. Robert Mugabe has led this country since it independence from Britain and his record for the first decade was decent but it is clear that his endurance in leadership has probably outlived its utility. Not only is the political scene characterized by necessarily toxic relationship to the Zimbabweans with different political views, but the intransigence in economic policy led to a disaster evident in the high rates of inflation and the collapse of that local currency.

And yet, given the human ingenuity and liberalized currency policy of the United States, the Zimbabwean Dollar has been replaced by the US currency as the effective currency. This happened because citizens of the country realized that harsh political rhetoric from the leadership is one thing but that the need to anchor their income to a stable currency was prudent. As Lydia Polgreen of the NYT covers in detail, all transactions have shifted to US dollars and the Zimbabwean dollar has all but disappeared. This has in turn had the effect that finding change for small transactions is difficult because of the absence of Us coins in that country. This relative shortage of coins reflects the fact that coins are more difficult to transport across long distances and also that seignorage allows paper currency to carry its value over long distances.     The lesson here is that money may be a store of value but it is also a commodity subject to demand. Just ask Zimbabweans.

Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Students Of Law Need Econ 101 More Than Deans

It is altogether sensible to posit that individuals pursue education with a view to improving their future income. This rule of thumb holds pretty well for a majority of people but it is not immutable. Many people pursuing education understand that attending college is definitely useful for raising the prospects for one's income. And yet as expected, the demand for education has to reckon with the supply of places by universities whose managers understand that certain courses have greater demand and price them accordingly.

In this pithy article in the Slate Magazine, Reynolds Holding applies fundamental economics reasoning to law schools and concludes that many of the deans have maintained an upwards price adjustment in real tierms despite the evidence that many graduates are often unable to pay for education loans due to a reduction in demand for graduates from law schools. His point is right but I am clear that it is not for the law deans to make an adjustment because they are seeking to maximize revenues and will price at the margin. Instead, this article ought to be read more keenly by the students entering law schools who ought to understand that given the employment situation and expected wages, education in law at prevailing rates may not be a good deal. It is clear that it is the students of law who are "irrationally exuberant". The law deans are merely providing supply due to existing demand. iIt matters less for the moment that the demand is based on an inaccurate assessment of expected incomes.   

Monday, April 16, 2012

Did Facebook Price Instagram Correctly?

Journalist covering technology reported late last week that Facebook acquired a fast-growing but not well-known application known as Instagram. That Facebook would make an acquisition of a photo sharing application was not as surprising as the price that was paid for the new firm. It was surprising because not only was the firm very small but had virtually no revenues yet. It appeared to me that the value ascribed to the firm by Facebook was on the higher side.  

Writing in the Guardian, John Naughton writes about the difficulty of valuation of technology firms and gives examples of valuations that brought acquiring corporations to grief. The gist of the article though is that there is an emerging bubble for technology firms. I am cautious in declaring that there is a definite bubble but the salient feature here is that valuation of firms is a matter of intelligent guesses filled with hopes of future performance. The valuations are not to be taken much too seriously and so the answer to title question of this post is unlikely to be answered with certainty.

Thursday, April 12, 2012

Busting Collusion Over Books

I did not record it on this blog but it occurred to me that the tough bargain that Apple reached with the publishers on e-books was potentially troublesome. At the time, the idea was that publishers wanted an alternative that ensured that they maintained control of the cost of e-books in the quest to break the perceived  stranglehold on the market by Amazon. Notwithstanding my admiration for Apple, I support the enquiry by the US Department of Justice with the claim that Apple and the publishers colluded to fix prices and thereby raise their revenues in way that was harmful to buyers.

Brian Balker of the Guardian provides the background together with details of the claim by the US Government here. In spite of my reluctance to support government intervention against businesses, I think that this has sufficient justification. To start with, Amazon had placed most publishers in a place where they were the prices of e-books were moving towards marginal cost. The agreement that forms the justification for this suit ensured that publishers maintained the bizarre pricing that made no sense to anyone else but the few publishers. Since then, even Amazon has had to be more cautious in pricing books because it could have been isolated since the iPad gave substantial power to Apple. 

Sunday, April 08, 2012

Latin American Leaders Start Assessment of Drugs War

For a whole generation, the world has concentrated on a law and order approach to the control and eradication of production and transportation of narcotics and other drugs. It is clear that this so-called war has been fought with public support and hard military responses but has not yielded acceptable results. The state of affairs in Latin America alone today's shows that there is need to accept that the approach has been unsuccessful. It is encouraging that in spite of the fact that the public in many countries are not naturally drawn to legalization and regulation, it is possible to form a persuasive case that the "War on Drugs" has failed.

Jamie Doward captures the frustrations of Otto Perez Mollina of Guatemala who hopes to convince his colleagues at an upcoming summit to consider a new approach. To my mind, this conversation is required even if the results of the discussion would be difficult to sell as apolitical decision. I applaud this because many other leaders in the neighborhood have been making similar declarations in light of the toll on human life. the political risks to the leaders attending the conference are real but there is no greater evidence than four decades of a well-articulated approach that has created insecurity and militarized drug trade and production.  This fresh approach alerts one to the idea that ideology is sometimes responsible for demonstrably poor public policy.

  

Wednesday, April 04, 2012

Who Needs a Financial Products Agency?

It is very clear to any keen observer that financial engineering does not necessarily result in products with social value. In many cases, those who work actively to design sophisticated financial products are not always certain of their real effects on markets or other products. Staring from this realization, it is unsurprising to me that many well-intentioned people are keen to ensure that financial engineering is limited to producing products with proven social value. Gretchen Morgenson of the NYT presents that same argument and features the paper by Eric Posner and E. Glen Weyl of the University of Chicago. The two professors state that there is a distinction between the real economy and the financial services industry and this may justify regulation of the latter and not the former.

The summary of their proposal contained in this paper is that the creation of a Financial Products Agency is necessary o ensure that there is adequate testing of the social value of new products before release to the market. To my mind, the reasoning about the distinction between real markets and the financial services industry is impeccable but the proposal for creating an agency for determining social value is less convincing. Indeed, I think that it is a very bad idea that is incapable of putting to effect. My reason for this skepticism is that the determination of social value would be difficult to determine because market participants would not define it in the same way. In addition, placing a regulatory committee to determine what social value a product would have is a very nebulous endeavor that would introduce subjectivity to these decisions.   

The only way for society to ensure that socially useful products continue to thrive is to communicate to institutions that generate these solutions that they will bear the costs of any failures. It is not necessary to require clairvoyance on the part of an agency or body.   

Monday, March 26, 2012

Tiger Woods Finally Wins PGA Tournament

Its surely been long and arduous, mixed with some disappointment but Tiger Woods finally won after more than two years. reports of his personal indiscretions notwithstanding, my view in several blog posts here, here and here has been that the skill level required of a golfer of such calibre remains with one for a considerable period. It was really just a metter of time before Tiger won resoundingly again, as happened over the weekend at the Arnold Palmer Invitational in Florida.

While the tenor of the CNN story is more measured and neutral, I think that many people had unwisely written off this athlete. All the naysayers and his competitors and former colleagues who have been critical played to the nature of sports journalism. The defining nature is to highlight momentary difficulty and try to show who is in decline against new entrants to the game. I am glad that Tiger is back and that he is doing his best where he has been among the best. he has time yet to make history. May this guy continue to prosper as his work ethic shows that he deserves it.     

Sunday, March 25, 2012

Minimum Alcohol Pricing Policy

In my view, one of the paradoxes in the control of substances harmful to health and with adverse effects is the differential policy options taken in respect of alcohol, tobacco and narcotics. Many times, sensible policy dialogue is carried out as if it is a given that narcotics are more harmful relative to alcohol. More importantly, it is often unacknowledged that price mechanism could be used as part of policy for alcohol and health policy. As this article in the Guardian states, the government of the United Kingdom is considering the introduction of a minimum price policy for alcoholic beverages in order to reduce binge consumption and effects on other people.

The details state that the policy would establish a price floor of 40 pence for every unit of alcohol and that this would reduce crimes and accidents. Understandably, the retailers argue that this policy would affect income groups differently because it would raise the costs of consumption disproportionately for poorer individuals. As described in the story, this effect would almost certainly be the case. To my mind, it is also the lower income people who are most vulnerable to the adverse effects of alcohol consumption.


Monday, March 19, 2012

Should We be Freed From Passwords?

It took me a while to realize that security in the Internet and related gadgets in use today is an arms race that will keep security consultants perpetually at work. This stance came to me after reading the analytical model that Bruce Schneier adopts to discussions on security. That notwithstanding, I was impressed with the idea expressed in this article by Randall Stross of the NYT. It correctly identifies that most people use very sloppy passwords by not giving much thought to it in addition to the fact that really strong passwords will be difficult to remember. In recognition of this human weakness, the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) has commenced thinking to go beyond passwords as known today.

This project seeks to design a mechanism that allows for use of a a connected device by detection of an individuals' user signature, which he calls "Cognitive Signature". This means that access and use of computers and devices will be left to software that has the ability to detect the individual's unique interaction pattern with the keyboard. "Keystroke Dynamics" are actions that are undertaken repeatedly and therefore not subject to deliberate thought. I sense that they would build a profile which will authenticate the user of the device. 

This is without doubt an extremely clever approach as the tests show that it is very difficult to consciously bypass. This will raise the threshold for those who would breach security but it also means that it will be difficult to log in people who are authorized to share a machine unless their "Keystroke Dynamics" is embedded in the system. Unlike Randall Stross who speaks of the password free environment as providing a near perfect environment,  I remain less sanguine. The requirement for simplicity of systems is part of the reason why securing computer systems remains difficult. I do not see how this password-free system makes it disappear. 

Thursday, March 15, 2012

Did Goldman Sachs Forget Obliquity?

My memory fails me in nailing where I read this comment but in discussions about Goldman Sachs, many people I know refer to the firm as the indisputable creator of millionaires every year. Being this great millionaire creation machine, it is clear that the professionals in there work extremely hard and provide value to their clients in order to retain them. And yet since the publication of this article in the NYT by an executive in the firm, the reputation of this firm stands in the balance. 

Greg Smith is without doubt an accomplished person and probably a millionaire as well but chose to state clearly why he felt that he cannot continue to work in the firm. His claims have understandably been denied by the firm but it is also clear that dispassionate commentaries should consider that he left on his own terms and is therefore unlikely to be an employees lashing back because of dismissal for poor performance.  The letter is clear that the ethos of the firm has changed from being marginally helpful to clients to the direct pursuit of opportunities to bill clients. That the letter specifically mentions the president and the CEO as particularly responsible for the sharp turn towards making money by all means and leaving clients to their own devices is telling. 

I am unsure that this state of affairs is merely about "moral bankruptcy" or obsession with billing clients only. I think that Goldman Sachs is far too large, influential and remains highly regarded by its clients probably too loyal to be damaged severely by George Smith's claim. That notwithstanding, it is still a measure of deep failure on the part of Goldman Sachs that a twelve year blameless staffer leaves with the thinking that the firm is lying to its client and providing professional services of dubious value. In my book, that is failure and this firm ought to get its executives to think seriously about what its very highly selected and capable workers think about it. Remember that the its external critics may be envious or ignorants but Greg Smith clearly falls in a different category. 

And my advise to Goldman Sachs' leadership: Please find this book and read it thoroughly. That expenditure will not be wasted. In addition, it is best for the firm's employees to learn some etiquette because denigrating clients by use of rude names is not classy.

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Airlines Getting Top Class Menus for Paying Fliers

In my view, air travel in economy class is burdensome and uncomfortable because of poor air circulation, cramped seating space and terrible food. I have sought a simple model of economics to explain this fact and sometimes conclude that space and air circulation are real problems but that food is a less genuine challenge but driven by the need to save funds since most travelers will not eat much anyway. I have had in mind that it is possible to vastly improve the quality of airline food but that it is not feasible immediately because of the conditions of its preparation, packaging and storage. As a result, I have often confirmed to myself that the incentive to create better food would not yield much advantage due to the thin margins that exist for this industry.

Reading this article in the NYT, I have confirmed a few of my hunches and also been vastly educated on some very brave assumptions that I made earlier. For instance, it appears that food changes taste dramatically with elevation and this may part of the problem in perceiving food quality in the air as less sumptuous. The taste buds and the nose, which are important for detection of flavor are changed substantially when a plane cruises miles high. And so this shows that it is not for want of effort but that one should not anticipate that dining in a plane will be as pleasurable as it is in one's kitchen or favorite restaurants.

That notwithstanding, selected airlines are attempting to improve the experience of business class passengers by consulting highly-regarded chefs to design menus for their airlines. The business case for this attempt is clear as there is a quest to improve the experience of the higher paying fliers. and so one sees competition among airlines in Europe and the United States in securing the services of top chefs to improve the food and beverage service. It is noteworthy that the economy class and domestic fliers are not going to partake of the same pleasures. The signal to the latter is clearly that an upgrade gets you eat from a menu designed by Gordon Ramsay. Payment for the activation of a discerning palate is available on the ground and coming to the air too.

I do not begrudge business class travellers at all. If only similar dedication was placed on solving the other problems of the freshness of cabin air and the more leg room.


Saturday, March 10, 2012

Cities and Building

"Successful cities must build in order to accommodate the rising demand for space, but that does not mean that building creates success." Edward Glaeser in, The Triumph of The City. P.53

Tuesday, March 06, 2012

Cato Institute's Moment of Trial

It has always been in my mind that think tanks generally provide a good ground for developing thinking and generating new policy ideas in society. Holding this truth asnd self-evident, I have always argued that there is a solid correlation between the number and quality of think tanks in a polity and the quality of life of citizens. Taking this idea further, I have maintained that the variety in quality of the think tanks is in many respects a measure of the fact that larger economies have surpluses and firms that may contribute towards the support of dispassionate thinking and idea generation.

I have posted a number of pieces on this blog such as this, this and this in which I mused on a number of issues pertinent to think tanks. Following a single visit years ago, I acquired and have often maintained enormous respect for the Cato Institute as the example of an ideas institution with rigorous analysis and a wide range of policy interests. Added to the fact that it is well-endowed with intellectual and financial resources, it remained in my eyes the libertarian's think tank. And yet it is clear that this think tank is about to go through an internal civil war that would leave its credibility in tatters and with a major loss of its secure financial base if a takeover that is being proposed by the Koch brothers is successful. 

David Weigel's article narrates about the sudden change that the institution would undergo if the composition of its Board of Directors changed as desired by leading financial supporters. It impresses me that the structure itself mirrors that of a corporation but the assertiveness of the new members is undesirable because it is specifically calculated to ensure that research and policy prescriptions take a predetermined political shape. The lesson of this event is that no individual should place political interests ahead of a working and respected institution and that when all this is done, Cato will not be the same again. It is impressive that the staff is clearly aware that this shift will affect their work adversely and are supportive of the president. May reason prevail.

Monday, March 05, 2012

Population Control for Dartmoor Ponies

It is not often that one encounters a problem related to the need to control animal populations in the world today. It is more frequently reported that a certain species of animal is faced with extinction all on account of human activity or demand for products of that animal. Tracy McVeigh of the Guardian reports here that the Dartmoor ponies in the UK have been over breeding and the authorities have designed a mechanism for birth control among the female animals in order to control their numbers. This is an elaborate system driven by a solution based on biology to reduce fertility and maintain numbers. It would be interesting to see how it works over the period of its implementation.

No doubt this approach will have some effect but my concern is that the story does not mention whether this was considered the most cost effective means for the identified problem. As I stated in a blog post a while ago, Australia had the same problem with its camel population and chose to shoot them from the air.  In both cases, my concern was that a solution was predetermined and there is no information whether the alternatives were chosen on the basis of cost effectiveness or merely because these were the methods that were most attractive to the decision makers. The question remains whether there may have been better solutions that were not considered.

   

Friday, February 24, 2012

Lessons From a New Copier

I was trying to figure out how to use the new copier in a certain corner of the office where I work when I noted that machine makers have a sense of humour. On the left hand corner of the surface of the plate is a warning stating that it is illegal to use this copier for generating photocopies of bank notes, cash, passports, certificates, securities and stamps. Having seen this, I rubbed my eyes and asked myself why this warning was necessary.

Thinking about it, it is clear to me that this item sells in various parts of the world and it may well be that in some countries, making copies of currency is forbidden. Now, the manufacturers of this machine seem to consider it their duty to warn users that making these copies would be criminal activity. I think that this manufacturer is being very kind to its customers but is merely reacting to the need to issue too many warnings in order to forestall any vexatious litigation.

To my mind, some managers considered that since the machine could be used to make forgeries, it may be in their interest to ensure that no person may claim that the machine facilitated criminal action. I am sure that this is not the way to go because people should understand that in purchasing a machine, the maker has in mind that it would be used for lawful purposes only. And that's why I was amused that a manufacturer of this machine assumes the responsibility for this warning. I would have thought that anybody who is capable of using this complicated gadget should know that copying currency may be a crime. The notice would be more accurate if its added that copying the following items with intent to use them as original is forbidden. 

Monday, February 20, 2012

Can Citizenship Be a Commodity?

Whereas many students of economics attribute little value to the issue of identity, it is a fact that professional political scientists and other people think that it is an important factor in political organization. The evidence for this is seen in the tendency for most decisions in public affairs to find interpretation from the standpoint of identity at macro or micro-levels. In a word, identity is real for most people and no wonder countries are organized in an exclusive sense with citizens recognized and the others labelled as foreigners.

There is a small degree of migration across countries with people prepared to take risks and uproot their families in pursuit of employment or security in other parts of the world. So what one sees is a real demand through legal and illegal means for entry into safer and more open countries with prosperous firms that may provide employment.

Mathew Yglesias of Slate Magazine writes about the Island of St Kitts and Nevis which offers citizenship for sale at the sum of US$ 250,000 per person. The article goes on to state that this steep price has not failed to attract takers and further that this market-based approach may serve the United States much better as an element of immigration policy. Needless to state, I am totally in agreement because if the demand for a product is high, then the real value could be captured by using a market mechanism both to ensure its distribution and also to make price act as the rationing mechanism. As Yglesias states, there is scope for tweaking the mechanism to ensure that there is diversity but that does not take away the validity of using the market to ensure that immigrants pay for the right of residency or settlement. To my mind, it matters not if other countries adopt the same policy because the market will ensure that each country's residency charge is adjusted according to the demand for settlement. Over time, that price would correlate highly with democracy and openness and would point to what conditions people prefer to live under.    


Friday, February 17, 2012

Apple Stock Reflects Value of its Products

In my view, Farhad Manjoo's articles in the Slate mMagazine have been reliable sources of information on technology. His latest piece involves the analysis on Apple and specifically its stock performance over time. bBased on the numbers in this article, the Apple stock has risen by more than 32% since the death of Steve Jobs  some months ago. The author identifies clear drivers of the stock price as being a good set of high margin products such as the iPad, iPhone and the Macintosh computers. All this is uncontroversial and the dominance of Apple in these markets suggest that its profits are guaranteed for a while. Indeed, Farhad goes on a limb and states, tongue in cheek perhaps, that he would recommend a buy for anyone with money to invest.

I agree that Apple stock is a great buy but I am less inclined to believe that any savvy person should consider the  P/E ratio in making that decision. My reason is that it is true that Apple's P/E ratio is still lower than that of other comparable firms but that should not lead to the conclusion that Apple's numbers should match those. It may just be that the other firms are now due for a downward adjustment. tThis change would still make Apple a good buy in relative terms and not necessarily because it would rise further. In other words, the P/E is a guide yes, but it does not tell one whether it is Apple that will rise or others with a lower ratio that will be coming down. Apple is a good buy because its management makes fine products with a higher margin that its competitors and which satisfy its buyers. With these factors established, the P/E ratio is a red herring.

 

  

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Lamy Muses on Free Trade and Food Security

Observers of the goings-on in the arena for international trade sometimes carry different views about the reason for the failure to complete the Doha Round. To my mind though, it is clear that one of the reasons that I discount is the claim that the WTO has not had truly capable leadership. In many respects, Pascal Lamy and his colleagues in Geneva are faced with the political problems that depress the possibility for substantial freeing of trade. 

One sees further evidence of the thought leadership and clear understanding of the fine but clear distinctions between the political and economic barriers to liberalization among countries. Addressing a policy audience during the Economist Conference early this month, Pascal Lamy ably dissects the issue of food security and the potential of trade to ease price shocks and shortages. The most poignant points in my mind is that very little food is traded across borders to begin with and further that governments are wont to respond to shocks by cutting off the movement of food across borders and thereby exacerbating that problem of supply and prices. Having observed that most food exports come from a ridiculously small number of countries, he unequivocally states that international trade in food is necessary to diversify sources by increasing competition and ensuring that supply comes from the most efficient producers. 

This is a very succinct summary of the state of agriculture products in world trade and good primer for introducing thinking around the benefits of trade. There is an obvious paradox that while the vast majority of the world's households derive livelihoods from agriculture, the proportion of their production that is traded stands at 7%. It cannot be difficult to figure out that the reason is the absence of free trade around agriculture. An old profession that is yet to be substantially freed from political encumbrances. 

Friday, February 10, 2012

Largest Embassy May Be White Elephant

Reading this article reminded me of an old blog post here on the US Embassy building in Baghdad. At the time, the tenor of the post was that this was the most expensive and expansive embassy building in the world at the time. At the time, the overall costs could have been attributed to the need to fortify the grounds that hold the building together with the residences of the embassy stuff. To my  mind then, it was also a testament to the fact that the US foresaw a continuing role for it in that country for the foreseeable future.

Five years hence, it is clear that the combat mission is being drawn down with the result that the compound now looks unwieldy. It illustrates that telling the course of war and US engagement in the future was not accurate at that time. At the same time, the concerns for safety of workers means that the embassy compound is a fort that does not predispose embassy staff to meeting with Iraqi's. So without looking at the vast expense, this embassy building risks becoming a white elephant. As one official asks, "what prompted the designers to build it in such scale?"


Sunday, February 05, 2012

General Uhm's Five Star Lecture on Development



The one area in which I concede to state involvement is the provision of security within institution run by constitution. I have noted with amazement the fact that in the US in particular, military leaders often find lucrative positions in directorships in corporations ostensibly to provide strategic views and insights. Today, I have just watched the clip by Peter Von Uhm, the Chief of Defense of The Netherlands and confirmed my view that some military leaders are indeed deep thinkers with an understanding of what their contribution to stability and peace is.

In the very incisive presentation, he alludes to his family's history as the motivation for his choice for military life and how the gun, while seen as a simple instrument of violence and conflict, qualifies as a peace builder when used in a controlled and legally regulated manner. He walks his listeners through historical data on conflicts and human suffering and how the world has become increasingly safe over the last few centuries and attributes this to democratic control of military and violence through states. As if that were not enough, he ties the story together with growth and development by stating the empirical fact that stability and trade beget further peace because trade and exchange make conflict unduly expensive. In this way, trade and peace are self-reinforcing. This would be fantastic teaching aid for a class on economics and development. 

Five star presentation from a five star general.   

Wednesday, February 01, 2012

Stopping The Gold Thieves

Reading through this article on the rise of burglaries and robberies that affects South Asians resident in the United Kingdom just got me thinking about the burdens of  wealth and the advantages of fiat money. That story highlights the rise of thefts among families from south asia who are known to keep substantial amounts of gold as savings.  This form of saving is attributed to the preference by these families to save through precious metals with a known record for keeping its value over generations.

It is unsurprising that when the owners of commodities in great demand may face the risk of theft especially when the price of gold has appreciated remarkably in recent times. To a thinking robber, it is probably less risky to steak jewelry from a family house than attempt a bank robbery or other goods. In addition, the package would be valuable and yet manageable both in terms of ease of hiding and the ability to convert the items into cash with minimum risk of detection. However, I am unsurprised that the owners of the property are unable to find either safe boxes in banks or  to insure their property. This does not make sense to me especially since the vulnerability to theft and conversion of gold would lead to equally ingenious ways for ensuring its safety. Thinking about the fact that a family that claims to live modestly owned that much gold suggests that a bank would offer to keep the property for a fee. In my sympathy for the loss of property keenly acquired over generations, I think a fee-based repository for the jewelry is missing from the market. In my estimation, it will not be long before it is available. This would be a good problem for a crowd sourcing solution.  

Business Leaders Dont Need Medals From State

I have never quite understood why people who work in difficult situations in commercial enterprises think so highly of gifts of recognition awarded by states and their agencies. This idea came back forcefully to me when I read that a former CEO of the Royal bank of Scotland has had a Knighthood recalled because of ostensible mismanagement of the firm in which he was head. Patrick Wintour of the Guardian writes that Fred Goodwin had the Knighthood recalled and the decision as communicated to him by by a committee of five officers of the State in the U.K.

To my mind, I think that irrespective of the demonstrated incompetence that Goodwin had exhibited, it surprises me that everyone seems to think that this affects his reputation adversely. My contention is that the state should not be giving the marks of ostentation to business people and imagine that they are very highly valued unless they were sold. I would like to find out how much Fred Goodwin would pay for the Knighthood if it were sold to him because then it would reflect objective value. Since the state used tax payers money to call Fred to a meeting and awarded a medal made out of the funds of other tax payers, I do not think that Fred should really mind giving it back.

Now, I hope that medal could be auctioned to the highest bidder and the money dedicated to better public purposes. the state has no reason to appease entrepreneurs who go into a business and excel because their reward should come from their enterprises. As it stands, I am unsure whether the recall means that the decision to award the medal was wrong in the first place and who is to take responsibility for that. 

Thursday, January 26, 2012

Africa's Tweet Data Means Nothing

It is a well-known that due to the availability of digital technology, there is a surfeit of data that represent human behaviour than ever. And yet the availability of vast amounts of data does not mean that it is necessarily more accessible or comprehensible. For instance, Portland, a firm that tracks technology uses has presented the results of its research in a chart appearing in image on this post and appearing on this datablog by Simon Rogers of the Guardian. The chart presents data on the the volume of Twitter messages sent within African countries. As is possible the image looks neat but I am certain that the chart tells the casual observer virtually nothing except that it was prepared by a person who does not understand the data that was collected.

To start with, there is a diversity of countries in Africa and so presentation of the absolute numbers is useful. However, there are number of school boy errors that emerge from that presentation. First, the placement of the data side by side invites comparisons among countries and creates the ranking system that the developers of the charts displays. This ranking is not possible because of the differences in population among these countries. Second, given the failure to account for the populations differences that are truly vast, the data cannot provide information that the heading of the chart purports. This second error may not be the fault of the data collectors but I suspect that the Guardian's data editors would spot this. The volume of messages are definitely provided by a different number of people in each country.  

Professors Experiment With College Education

I keep wondering how different education will be supplied and consumed in a couple of decades when digitization will be more mature. My wondering was in part reflected in this blog post in which I linked to an article about the MIT having introduced an e-learning course for which certification would be provided to participants. To my mind, the MIT may have been experimenting with a system which would then be varied and then used to inform the methods for delivering university-level education in the future. And the provision of certificates was the institution's way of ensuring that it has sufficient takers to allow for the experiment to yield meaningful results while assessing demand.

Sebastian Thrun, a professor from MIT learned from the huge demand for the free course on artificial intelligence and opted to convert that into a business opportunity. As MSNBC reports, the business will provide online education through video instruction with the teacher's time used in helping students to solve problems. This model is not a radical invention as the Khan Academy has a comparable model except that the latter is provided for open participation and with points accumulation as the evidence of accomplishment.

I am quite surprised that Sebastian Thrun resigned from MIT and is becoming a competitor in the provision of education services. It is difficult to assess the prospects of the new business but my view is that the demand that was expressed could follow the new business and this experiment means that soon, the top schools may have to consider taking the competition to their former employees. The MIT should consider taking over Udacity.  One cannot say anymore that technology is not changing education.  

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Blackberry's Wrong Call

Soon after the election of president Obama in November 2008, the press made reports about the fact that he would have to let go of his Blackberry device because it was not approved communication device for the US president. At the time, I stated on this posted a blog post stating that Research In Motion, the makers of the Blackberry set of devices, ought to have taken the opportunity to assert that its systems were quite robust and that the security features could be comparable to considered alternatives. In my view then, their failure to pitch in here may have been a chance lost for high-powered marketing irrespective of whether the challenge was taken up or not.

Three years later, it is clear that Blackberry has had a difficult time and has lost a lot of ground to its competitors in that smart phone market. Its struggle in that market has culminated in the the resignation of its leadership team and replacement of the Chief eExecutive Officer. Juliette Garside of the Guardian reports that the slide in market share and the share price prompted the changes in management as the firm struggled to provide new gadgets.

While I still think that the firm will continue to provide its gadgets in spite of the lower market share, its new management will be required to make tough choices with no guarantee of success. To my mind, this episode illustrates the fact that the technology industry is not only dynamic but that it is difficult to tell what clients will buy in the future in addition to executing business plans perfectly.


Thursday, January 19, 2012

The iPad as a Textbook

A couple of months ago, I stated in this post that Steve Jobs of Apple had stated to his biographer that information technology had not demonstrated revolutionary value for education. My interpretation is that he foresaw that the one area where this could happen would be to digitize textbooks and thereby undercut the huge rents that go to publishers every year.  It appears that the corporation has taken this further by attempting to build on the success of the iPad to deliver textbooks and other applications for young learners. Cecilia Kang of the Washington Post reports on the business approach taken by Apple in introducing a number of new approaches to delivering an interesting learning experience for learners.

There is a definite concern about the possible lock-in effect that would result from widespread adoption of the iPad and related software from Apple. Even assuming that this will be successful, one has to consider whether the quest to break the hold that textbook publishers have on education is worth breaking in exchange for the possibility of better education outcomes. I am inclined to believe that the delivery of education would be improved substantially and it is less likely that Apple would dominate for long since other manufacturers of tablet computers would be able to provide the same textbooks on their platforms.  An additional advantage is that the use of iPads and other tablets will call for innovative ways of delivering lessons. 

Wednesday, January 18, 2012

Politicians Take on Banning Pyjamas In Public

One of the paradoxes about the United States is that it is a nation that is truly given to respecting individual freedom and yet one also finds petty bureaucrats who try to limit choices in ridiculous ways. An MSNBC story covers the story in Louisiana where a state official is making proposals to stop people from wearing pajama pants in public. Now, one just wonders why such a ridiculous idea should be given any consideration. Wearing pyjamas in public is unsightly but I think that it is silly to put forth legislation to ban this and then have to fund the enforcement of that law.

To my mind, several cities have attempted to ban the appearance of individuals in public but I am unsure that the numbers of people engaged in this and the cost of enforcement make it even worthy of considering. My advise is for this guy to find soem other more important issues to dedicate his regulatory creativity on. Just look the other way when one person walks past you in the street. they are suppossed to live in a free country!

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

Diet Industry Under Pressure

If there is a trend in the globe today, it is that people question legitimately whether all financial institutions and instruments have any social value besides ensuring commissions and revenue for those who generate them. And while I understand that there are firms and individuals who are culpable for destroying value and harming clients, I am still clear that there are equally lucrative industries that are based on unverifiable myths. Reading this article a couple of days ago, it occurred to me that the slimming and dieting industry is one that sells products, books and services that do not only have dubious value but occasionally built on unsubstantiated scientific claims. 

Speaking of the weight loss "industry", I think that the use of celebrities to endorse products is not in itself objectionable. What I find ridiculous is that people are made to believe that a thirty day special programme would in itself lead to permanent shedding of unwanted weight. It is no surprise that a good proportion of those who successfully shed weight while on the plans do end up accumulating it all over again. In many instances, people take on diets based entirely on perceptions on what ideal weight should be and the preponderance of weight loss regimes suggests that this in itself is an industry that feeds its anxious clients incomplete information. Perhaps all firms in the industry should take pay based on their success rates. 

The reasonable response should be public education to ensure that individuals are able to make decisions based on evidence. That aside, there is need to deemphasize the idea that there is an epidemic obesity as I think that intervention by government will affect individual freedoms.

 

Sunday, January 15, 2012

Economics of Income for Clergy

Some of the literature available suggests that the major determinants of a person's income would be a combination of skills level, scarcity of the skills and therefore the amount of competition available and perhaps the degree of specialization. Brian Palmer's article in Slate Magazine compares the nominal incomes of individuals who provide religious services in the United States. I am surprised by the revelation not only because I have never considered this issue but also because the piece reveals interesting differences in the institutional organization of the various faiths.

Clearly, judging from the income reported, it appears that it is more financially rewarding to be a Rabbi. In trying to explain the reason for this, it is notable that Rabbi's tend to have more training and are comparatively likely to have made higher investment in their professional life on account of the longer training duration. On the other hand it is also clear that due to their numbers, Christian churches are in competition with one another and this inevitably drives compensation for pastors towards the marginal wage. It would be useful to determine the standard deviation across wages for all professionals providing religious services in addition to finding out which specific faith has the highest inequality within its professional cadre. My guess would be that the protestant Christian churches would have the highest inequality because the pastors of the mega-churches are in a different league and are a minority.

To my mind, it can be stated respectfully that the provision of religious services across monotheistic religions is amenable to analysis through basic tools of price theory. This labour market shows sensitivity to the amount of skill and the professionals therein are also able to supplement income by taking up other employment. Finally, it is clear that competition with the distinct faiths affects the income for individual pastors.  

Wednesday, January 11, 2012

Are Nigerian Protests Justifiable?

This year started on a very difficult note for the government of Nigeria generally and for the president in particular. Not only is the country faced with a problem of armed groups attacking civilians ostensibly to enforce religious homogeneity, the government made a critical but unpopular decision in economic policy. The latter decision involved the suspension of subsidies on petroleum with the immediate result that prices went up substantially. To my mind though, it is most surprising that the public demonstrations throughout the major cities have been organized to try and force the government to reverse the economic policy while the press that I refer to has not reported equally public campaigns for government action to respond to the loss of lives from cowardly armed groups.

This blogger will say no more than that no government that is legitimately elected should succumb to political pressure emanating from groups driven by an ideology that holds no respect for life. Indeed, the government's feeble response to the bombings and murders is the main point of weakness that I see. Regarding the suspension of subsidies, it may well be that the timing is unfortunate but it is clearly sensible economic policy. Reading this story, it is evident that the protests that issued on account of rising fuel prices causes difficulty to some citizens but I am certain that the incidence of the benefits of a subsidy on petroleum fuel is taken by the car owners and middle class people. The claim that this resultant price hike harms the poorest is demonstrably untrue because the owners of vehicles in this country are unlikely to be the indigent. Besides my regret in the damage to property and the risks faced by law enforcement officers, I think that this is an urban middle class bawling for subsidies at the expense of poorer Nigerians.

The moral of the story: there is never a right time to pull back subsidies even if in most cases, abolishing subsidies is the right economic policy. 

Tuesday, January 10, 2012

Truth About Japanese Economy

Judging from the surfeit of press and other commentary on Japan, one would get the erroneous impression that following the joint collapse of Japanese financial institutions and property markets in the late 1990's, that economy has remained perpetually in limbo.  In this article, Eamon Fingleton provides proper perspective to the issue through reminders that perception is starkly different from reality. While I have never visited Japan, most of what I watch shows that the citizens of that country enjoy a very high standard of living.

While it is true that Japanese corporations that dominated financial and technology markets ceded their position to other corporations, the economic adjustment within Japan did not cause a collapse. True, the rate of growth has not been high, but Japanese incomes have kept an upward creep and in some areas, the quality of technology and other services available within Japan are the enviable standards. While being cautious about Eamon's claims, it is still relevant to mention that Japan's early growth was sufficiently sound to ensure that the painful adjustments due to the property and bank crashes did not devastate its citizens. in short, Japan may not have caught up with the United States but its standards of living are still high and other fast growing countries would accomplish a lot by just getting to where Japan is. 

I am less sanguine about the argument that the citizens took a conscious decision to keep very low population growth. It is clear that the demographic position as it exists would soon have adverse effects on the growth of that country. It may well be that its economic policies were mostly sound but the desire to maintain strict racial homogeneity may be attractive social and cultural policy but is surely disastrous economic policy. Its time for Japan to review that because this is perhaps its most pressing policy failure today.     

Saturday, January 07, 2012

Sports Organizations and Corruption

The title of this blog post came to me as I read this article and tried to relate it to other instances where strong evidence of corruption in international sport has been revealed. It addresses the disclosure that an official of a boxing institution was curiously present in the front during the contest between Amir Khan and Lamont Peterson some weeks ago. Khan's team alleges that this official may have adversely influenced the judges.

To be honest, notwithstanding my reference to to FIFA in this post, I am generally suspicious of conspiracy theories. However, it is clear that the incentives for improper behavior are clearly available in lucrative sports disciplines. It seems that officials at the boxing match under reference acted in a less than transparent manner and this has called to question the decision of the fight.

I agree now that incentives for corruption in private bodies is high and that the international sports organizations should be a lot more transparent in their financial and contractual affairs. Granted that a majority of them are private organizations and therefore subject to scrutiny by their membership alone, I am inclined to the belief that their monopoly status adds to the opacity.  

Wednesday, January 04, 2012

Why Expensive Musical Instruments Do Not Sound Better

There are several ways in which conventional wisdom and expert opinion is very sensible advice but my reading of Freakonomics has led me to agree that what is the consensus and unquestioned wisdom is frequently plainly wrong and based on no evidence. Ian Sample of the Guardian writes about the results of a modest experiment with persuasive results that tested the claim that antique musical instruments (specifically violins) have a superior sound to more modern versions. Granted that there are limitations to the experiment principally related to the blindfolding of the players together with the small sample of the instruments, I am persuaded that its results are valid.

What the results show is that the instruments that are highly valued as having been created by a master such as Antonio Stradivari do not produce superior sound that it detectable to expert players. As the story states, these unique instruments are very highly valued by collectors and performers and are the prices are often justified on account of their superior quality of sound. What the results imply is that the less valuable instruments are probably not inferior in this respect. To my mind, the value of the Stradivarius instrument is most probably based on their rarity and scarcity. In addition, most of the owners of these antique instruments are very capable musicians whose skill may give the impression that that quality of performance is produced by the rare instrument. Instead, its just that the skill is the real magic.

These findings trace the continuing realization that most claims such as the superior taste of expensive wines, performance of maestros and now the sound quality of antique musical instruments, sometimes fails when subjected to randomized testing.